Car Insurance in Ohio by City

Written by Kevin Berry and 1 other
Updated Feb 10, 2025

Getting multiple quotes for car insurance can help save you money in Ohio.

City view of Cleveland, OH
You’re minutes away from insurance savings.

Car insurance rates in Ohio can vary based on where you live within the state. Depending on if you are up north in Akron or out west near Lima, it can make a difference in how much you pay for car insurance.

While the Ohio city you live in is one factor, there are many others that go into your car insurance rate such as your age, type of vehicle, coverage limits and your driving history.

We’ve collected the average monthly car insurance rates that drivers in Ohio have been quoted via Jerry from various cities. Find your city, or one nearby, to see what you could expect to pay — and use that information as you shop for car insurance.

See robust car insurance pricing for Columbus.

SIMPLIFY YOUR OHIO CAR INSURANCE IN MINUTES

Car insurance in Akron, OH

If you’re shopping for car insurance in Akron, Ohio, be sure to get quotes from companies like Progressive, Safeco and Trexis, who have often quoted Jerry customers affordable rates.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
Progressive $166
Trexis $168
Safeco $184
Commonwealth Insurance $206
National General $208
Last Updated May 25, 2025

Car insurance in Canton, OH

In Canton, car insurance companies like Embark, Trexis and Progressive have quoted solid rates for Jerry customers.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
Progressive $143
Commonwealth Insurance $145
Trexis $153
First Acceptance $194
Root $204
Last Updated May 25, 2025

Car insurance in Cleveland, OH

If you need car insurance in Cleveland, get multiple quotes from companies like Safeco, Progressive or Trexis to make sure you’re getting a competitive rate.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
Safeco $123
Progressive $159
Commonwealth Insurance $177
Trexis $190
Dairyland $212
Last Updated May, 2025
SIMPLIFY YOUR CAR INSURANCE IN MINUTES

Car insurance in Lima, OH

For those who live and drive in the Lima area, check out insurers like Progressive, The General and Commonwealth for competitive rates.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
Progressive $114
Trexis $136
Commonwealth Insurance $139
Dairyland $140
The General $153
Last Updated May 28, 2025

Car insurance in Mansfield, OH

Need car insurance in the Mansfield area? Shop around with companies like Commonwealth, Gainsco and Trexis for rates below the Ohio state average.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
Gainsco $115
Trexis $116
Commonwealth Insurance $121
Progressive $133
National General $160
Last Updated May 23, 2025

Car insurance in Ravenna, OH

If you need car insurance in Ravenna, look to companies like Commonwealth, Safeco or Dairyland who have often quoted affordable rates to Jerry customers.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
Commonwealth Insurance $92
Bristol West $106
The General $110
Progressive $111
Safeco $115
Last Updated May 25, 2025
SIMPLIFY YOUR CAR INSURANCE IN MINUTES

Car insurance in Springfield, OH

Shopping for car insurance in Springfield should give you several good options to pick from including the likes of Safeco, Commonwealth and The General.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
Commonwealth Insurance $95
Trexis $101
The General $102
Bristol West $118
Progressive $136
Last Updated May 23, 2025

Car insurance in Warren, OH

Drivers in the Warren area have gotten low-cost rates from insurers like Safeco, Commonwealth and Clearcover according to Jerry customer data.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
Safeco $83
Commonwealth Insurance $108
Assurance America $127
Progressive $147
Trexis $169
Last Updated May, 2025

Car insurance in Youngstown, OH

Car insurance in Youngstown doesn’t have to be expensive. Get prices from companies such as Progressive, Commonwealth and Trexis who have often quoted Jerry customers rates below the Ohio state average.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
Progressive $117
The General $144
Trexis $147
National General $163
Commonwealth Insurance $179
Last Updated May 23, 2025

Car insurance in Zanesville, OH

You should find several affordable car insurance options in Zanesville including Safeco, Gainsco and Trexis.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
Safeco $85
Commonwealth Insurance $92
Trexis $103
Progressive $111
The General $115
Last Updated May 25, 2025
SIMPLIFY YOUR CAR INSURANCE IN MINUTES

Methodology

Data for all tables includes quotes in the last 18 months for Jerry customers in the designated city with no violations.