Get started Log in
Insurance Car Care Driver Safety

Insurance Types

Company

Download Jerry today
Log in Get started

Best Car Insurance Companies in 2026

Jerry is a free app trusted by over 5 million drivers nationwide that compares insurance quotes from 100+ insurers.

  • Get personalized options in minutes.

  • Buy, bundle and switch right in the app.

  • Licensed agents are ready to help if you need them.

Get Quotes
Stephanie Colestock
Author
Stephanie Colestock
Insurance Writer

GEICO is the best car insurance company overall for most drivers in 2026, balancing a high Jerry Score rating (4.1 out of 5) with availability in all 50 states and one of the widest discount lineups in the industry. Amica earns Jerry’s highest rating (4.4 out of 5) on the strength of its claims and service record, and is the top pick for drivers who prioritize claims experience. Erie and USAA also rate 4.2. Eligibility and state availability vary, so be sure to compare your own rates by getting personalized quotes in minutes through Jerry.

Best car insurance companies of 2026 at a glance

The picks below are ordered by overall rank: a blend of factors like Jerry’s own proprietary rating, each insurer’s market reach and product availability. Star ratings reflect the Jerry Score rating only.

Insurance company

Best for

Jerry Score star rating (out of 5)

GEICO

Overall car insurance

4.1

Amica

Claims experience (highest rated)

4.4

Progressive

Drivers with violations

3.7

Allstate

Safe-driver programs

3.9

USAA

Military and veterans

4.2

Travelers

Higher-value vehicles

4.1

Farmers

Coverage customization

3.8

Erie

Customer satisfaction (regional)

4.2

State Farm

Working with national agents

3.6

Auto-Owners

Working with regional agents

4.0

Car insurance calculator

Your personal rate estimate in 60 seconds

Best car insurance companies, reviewed

Here’s a deeper look at our picks for the best car insurance companies, what they offer and why Jerry drivers choose them.

GEICO: Best overall

Geico
4.1
Jerry rating
Our take
GEICO is the strongest all-around choice for the widest range of drivers in 2026. It offers more than a dozen ways to discount premiums, has one of the better-rated mobile apps, and earned the highest financial-strength rating from AM Best (A++). Coverage is available in all 50 states, including for many high-risk drivers who struggle to find coverage elsewhere.
Pros
  • Many rate discount opportunities.
  • High financial strength rating.
  • Available in all 50 states.
  • Files SR-22 forms for high-risk drivers.
Cons
  • Does not offer gap insurance.
  • Below-average customer satisfaction ratings from J.D. Power.
Compare quotes with Jerry
  • GEICO discounts
  • Optional GEICO coverages

Why it made the list

GEICO takes the top overall slot for pairing top-tier financial strength with all-50-state availability and a wide discount menu. This makes it the broadest fit for the most Jerry drivers.

Industry ratings at a glance:

More: Compare car insurance quotes

Amica: Best for claims experience

Amica
4.4
Jerry rating
Our take
Amica earns Jerry’s highest rating in 2026. It is a mutual insurer, owned by its policyholders rather than shareholders, and holds some of the highest claims and customer-satisfaction scores. Its policies automatically include features like new car replacement, identity-theft monitoring and full glass coverage — things most carriers charge extra for. Its reach is smaller than the bigger national brands, which affects its ranking.
Pros
  • Earned the highest Jerry Score this year.
  • Top claims and customer-satisfaction ratings.
  • Feature-rich policies.
  • Mutual insurer offering potential dividends.
Cons
  • Limited availability.
  • Above-average pricing for base coverage.
Compare quotes with Jerry
  • Amica discounts
  • Optional Amica coverages

Why it made the list

Amica earned the highest rating in our review based on the strength of its claims and customer-satisfaction record, and leads on service rather than price.

Industry ratings at a glance:

Lifestyle2 1

Compare 100+ insurers through Jerry in less than 5 minutes

Compare quotes

Progressive: Best for drivers with a violation or accident

Progressive
3.7
Jerry rating
Our take
Progressive is one of the few major insurers that is competitive for drivers with tickets, accidents or DUIs, and it’s among the largest and most widely available carriers in the country. Its Name Your Price tool lets drivers set a budget, and the Snapshot telematics program offers a route toward lower rates for safe drivers. It’s available in all 50 states and has a financially stable AM Best rating (A+).
Pros
  • Available in all 50 states.
  • Competitive for drivers with tickets, accidents or DUIs.
  • Name Your Price tool and Snapshot telematics program.
  • Files SR-22s.
  • Strong digital experience.
Cons
  • Low claims satisfaction rating from J.D. power.
  • Clean-record drivers may find better value elsewhere.
Compare quotes with Jerry
  • Progressive discounts
  • Optional Progressive coverages

Why it made the list

Few major carriers compete as hard for drivers with tickets, accidents or DUIs. Progressive backs that with 50-state availability and a strong digital experience.

Industry ratings at a glance:

Allstate: Best for safe-driver programs

Allstate
3.9
Jerry rating
Our take
Allstate‘s Drivewise program tracks driving habits and can cut premiums by up to 40%, and its Milewise pay-per-mile option is worth a look for low-mileage drivers. It’s a large national brand available in all 50 states with strong financial strength ratings, but customer reviews and claims ratings lag.
Pros
  • Offers rewards for safe driving.
  • Available in all 50 states.
  • Pay-per-mile option for low-mileage drivers.
  • Strong financial strength rating (A+).
Cons
  • Above average NAIC complaint index.
  • Lacks unique optional coverages.
Compare quotes with Jerry
  • Allstate discounts
  • Optional Allstate coverages

Why it made the list

Allstate makes the list for having one of the most generous safe-driver programs in the industry (Drivewise discounts go as high as 40%) alongside nationwide availability and a top-tier J.D. Power rating. That said, customer-satisfaction and claims scores hold its ranking back.

Industry ratings at a glance:

Learn More: Should you bundle home and auto insurance?

Lifestyle9

See coverage options for your car.

Compare quotes

USAA: Best for military members and veterans

USAA
4.2
Jerry rating
Our take
USAA earns the highest customer-satisfaction and digital-experience scores in our review and offers competitive rates for those who qualify. It’s a large, widely recognized carrier, but membership is limited to active military, veterans, and their immediate families — the reason it isn’t a general overall pick.
Pros
  • Highest customer-satisfaction and digital-experience scores in our review.
  • Competitive rates and tailored discounts for those who qualify.
  • Top financial strength rating (A++).
Cons
  • Eligibility limited to military, veterans, and their immediate families.
Compare quotes with Jerry
  • USAA discounts
  • Optional USAA coverages

Why it made the list

USAA earns its place for having high customer-satisfaction and industry ratings, plus competitive discounts for those who qualify. Membership is limited to the military community, which affects its availability.

Industry ratings at a glance:

Learn More: Types of car insurance coverage

Travelers: Best for higher-value vehicles

Travelers
4.1
Jerry rating
Our take
Travelers is one of the largest auto insurers in the country with a wide coverage menu, including new car replacement, accident forgiveness and rideshare coverage. Policies are offered in all 50 states and work well for drivers who want broad protection on newer or higher-value vehicles.
Pros
  • Available in all 50 states.
  • Top financial strength rating (A++).
  • Optional coverages include new car replacement, accident forgiveness and rideshare.
  • Strong option for bundling home and auto.
Cons
  • Prices near or above the national average, making it less ideal for budget shoppers.
Compare quotes with Jerry
  • Travelers discounts

Why it made the list

Travelers makes the list for top-tier financial strength and one of the widest optional-coverage catalogs, a fit for newer or higher-value vehicles. Its rating reflects coverage breadth more than price, which runs near or above average.

Industry ratings at a glance:

Mini1

Jerry pulls up to 20 quotes from top rated carriers.

Compare quotes

Farmers: Best for coverage customization

Farmers
3.8
Jerry rating
Our take
Farmers offers the longest list of optional add-ons on this list, including glass deductible buyback, new original parts and rental alternative coverage that pays for rideshare services while your car is in the shop. It’s a large national brand and a strong pick for drivers who want to build a truly customized policy.
Pros
  • Many optional add-ons.
  • Niche coverages like glass deductible buyback, new original parts, and rental alternative.
  • Wide variety of discounts.
Cons
Compare quotes with Jerry
  • Farmers discounts
  • Optional Farmers coverages

Why it made the list

Farmers takes the customization slot for the longest list of optional add-ons here, from glass deductible buyback to rideshare-while-in-the-shop coverage. That breadth drives its rating, set against a 42-state footprint.

Industry ratings at a glance:

Erie: Best for customer satisfaction

Erie
4.2
Jerry rating
Our take
Erie earned the strongest claims-satisfaction ratings from J.D. Power and top spot in the most recent shopping survey among all carriers. It also has high overall customer ratings from Jerry drivers . Coverage is regional (only offered in 12 states and Washington, D.C.) so it’s a strong pick for drivers in those locations, but its limited reach keeps it from earning one of the top overall spots.
Pros
Cons
  • Regional and available in only 12 states plus D.C.
  • Sold through local agents, not fully online.
  • AM Best rating was recently downgraded.
Compare quotes with Jerry
  • Erie discounts
  • Optional Erie coverages

Why it made the list

Erie earns the strongest J.D. Power shopping ranking nationwide and one of the highest CRASH network grades, but coverage is in just 12 states plus D.C.. This keeps it in a regional-satisfaction slot rather than the overall running.

Industry ratings at a glance:

lifestyle3

It only takes 2 minutes to sign up at Jerry.

Compare quotes

State Farm: Best for working with national agents

State Farm
3.6
Jerry rating
Our take
State Farm is the largest auto insurer in the country and runs the biggest local-agent network, which makes it the default for drivers who want in-person service almost anywhere they live. It writes auto policies in 48 states plus D.C. (excluding Massachusetts and Rhode Island for new policies, though it has announced plans to re-enter Massachusetts). Its Jerry rating trails behind some of the other top picks, weighed down by claims and reputation marks rather than financial strength or complaints.
Pros
  • Largest local-agent network in the country.
  • Available in 48 states plus D.C.
  • Strong financial strength rating (A+, Superior) and a solid complaint record.
  • Top-five finish in J.D. Power’s most recent shopping study.
Cons
  • Not available for new auto policies in all states.
  • Customer-satisfaction and reputation marks lag behind the top-rated carriers.
  • Recently downgraded AM Best score.
Compare quotes with Jerry
  • State Farm discounts
  • Optional State Farm coverages

Why it made the list

State Farm holds the nationwide agent slot on availability rather than score: it’s the largest auto insurer in the country with the biggest local-agent network, available in 48 states plus D.C. Its rating is lower than many of leaders show here, mostly due to claims and reputation scores, but for drivers who want face-to-face service almost anywhere, no one else matches State Farm’s availability.

Industry ratings at a glance:

Auto-Owners: Best for working with regional agents

Auto-Owners
4.0
Jerry rating
Our take
Auto-Owners combines a reputation for affordable car insurance rates with one of the lowest complaint records in our review. The trade-off is that it’s only available in 26 states and requires you to work with a local agent, which may be a downside for online- and mobile-based drivers who prefer a hands-off approach.
Pros
Cons
  • Available in only 26 states.
  • Direct agent model.
  • AM Best score was recently downgraded (2024).
Compare quotes with Jerry
  • Auto-Owners discounts
  • Optional Auto-Owners coverages

Why it made the list

Auto-Owners earns its spot thanks to one of the lowest complaint records in our review, a top-five J.D. Power study finish and a reputation for affordable rates. Its agent-only model and 26-state footprint make it the pick for drivers who want a local agent.

Industry ratings at a glance:

Lifestyle4

Jerry helps you bundle home and auto for less in just minutes.

Compare quotes

Choosing the best car insurance for your coverage needs

Even if your policy comes from a stellar insurance company, if it covers too much or too little, then it really isn’t the best one for you. Most drivers buy full coverage over liability-only policies, but if your car is old and low in value it might not be worth it. Additionally, liability limits come in many options — your state’s mandated limits may not be enough to cover a big hospital bill or totaled vehicle.

Choosing between minimum and full coverage

To qualify as the best car insurance, your policy must provide the right coverage. The difference between minimum and full coverage comes down to your budget and desired amount of protection, unless you have a loan or a lease that requires comprehensive and collision insurance.

Minimum coverage: Your state’s minimum required insurance is just that — the least amount of insurance you can buy in order to comply with the law. Some states only require property damage and bodily injury liability coverages, which are designed to cover the damage you cause to other people in an accident. These policies don’t help repair damage to your car if you cause an accident, but they usually have the most affordable premiums.

Full coverage: Full coverage is a term for a policy that includes liability, collision and comprehensive insurances. Full coverage can pay to repair your vehicle after an accident, regardless of who is at fault. It also covers damage caused by non-collision events, like theft, vandalism and weather hazards. Full coverage policies may also have higher liability limits, which protect people with more assets in case they are sued. These policies provide holistic financial protection, but they carry higher premiums than minimum coverage.

Choosing the best auto liability limits for you

Whether you get full coverage or not, you will need to determine your liability insurance limits. This is the amount your insurer will pay out to others if you cause an accident that injures someone or damages their property. If you need legal assistance over such a crash, this coverage also pays those fees, and any damages you owe in a lawsuit. If those costs exceed your liability limits after a crash, you’d have to come up with the rest yourself.

While some insurance companies only offer the minimum, state-mandated coverage, many well-known insurers offer liability limits for injuries up to $250,000 per person and $500,000 per crash, with $250,000 in property damage liability coverage. This is also expressed as 250/500/250 and covers a lot more than minimum coverage, but some drivers with high net worth may want to add an umbrella policy for even more coverage. Financial experts often recommend 100/300/100 for most drivers.

Choosing the right car insurance deductibles

If you buy a full coverage auto policy, your comprehensive and collision portions will come with a deductible, or amount you’ll need to put toward car repairs before the company pays. Deductible options typically range from $250 to $2,500 and choosing a higher amount will translate to a lower premium.

That might make the highest deductible seem attractive, but think about how much you could afford to pay in an emergency for car repairs and go from there. If you can’t get your car out of the shop because you’re short on funds, buying the cheapest car insurance coverage could cost you more in the long run.

Additional coverage types to tailor your policy

Despite the name, full coverage car insurance isn’t the most you can buy. With some companies, you can custom-build the best car insurance policy by adding coverage beyond the basics.

  • Uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage (UM/UIM) pays out if a driver with no liability coverage causes a crash and injures you or damages your property. It will also pay out if a driver who hits you has some liability coverage, but not enough to pay for all damages. UM and UIM can be sold together or separately, but not in limits higher than your liability coverage, and they typically come with a small deductible.
  • MedPay or personal injury protection (PIP) both provide medical coverage for you and your passengers if you’re injured in a wreck, though PIP can also pay out for lost wages and other costs. You can typically only buy one or the other, and PIP is more commonly required than MedPay.
  • Gap insurance pays out if your new car is totaled and you still have a balance on your auto loan or lease after your comprehensive or collision pays to their limit. That limit is the cash value of your car, which depreciates quickly in the first year or two of ownership. If you don’t have gap insurance and your car is totaled when the loan or lease balance is higher than the car’s value, you’d need to pay the difference — plus your deductible.

How to choose the best car insurance company for you

The best car insurance company isn’t the same for every driver, so it’s important to not only shop around for coverage through a platform like Jerry, but also take a personalized approach in the process.

  1. Consider your specific needs. Do you have an expensive car, remaining auto loan balance or lease, or would struggle to replace your vehicle in a pinch? Then a full coverage policy with comprehensive and collision insurance is probably the best option. On the other hand, if you have a spotty driving record or need an SR-22 filed, you may want to look at insurance companies that specializes in high-risk drivers to find a decent price.
  2. Research insurers. Reviewing auto insurers’ reputations before you buy helps you understand what their claims record is like and whether their current customers feel they get good service. Jerry reviews top insurers and collects customer reviews so you can always make the most informed decision.
  3. Get multiple quotes. Insurers use many factors to set your premium inducing your age, gender, location, vehicle and driving history — and they all weigh those factors differently. This means you may get different quotes across multiple insurers. Through Jerry, you can compare quotes from 100+ insurers in just minutes with no spam calls or obligation.
  4. Find discounts. Nearly all insurers offer discounts to help you save on costs, but some have a broader discount menu than others. USAA’s discounts cater to military drivers, for example, while Auto-Owners and Amica help good students save.

Car insurance FAQ

  • Which car insurance company is best overall in 2026?
  • Which companies offer the best safe-driving discounts?
  • Which company is best for drivers with a ticket or accident?
  • Which company is best for working with an agent?
  • Is it worth switching car insurance in 2026?
  • How quickly can I get a new policy?

Methodology

Statistics, rates and conclusions in this article are based on Jerry’s proprietary database of real-world car insurance quotes, not third-party models or estimates. As a licensed insurance broker in all 50 states, Jerry has firsthand visibility into how quotes are generated and validated, and all data is aggregated and anonymized to protect privacy. With millions of quotes delivered each year (often multiple offers per driver), our datasets are large enough to avoid bias toward any one region, insurer or driver type.

Unless otherwise indicated, quotes shown are from drivers with clean records in the last 12 months. Quotes involving accidents, violations or credit use the last 18 months to ensure a reliable sample.

How we rate car insurance companies

Jerry’s team of car insurance expert writers and editors analyzes real customer ratings, regulatory data and industry reports to evaluate each insurer across the factors that matter most when shopping for and using auto insurance: claims handling, customer satisfaction, complaint volume, coverage breadth, cost and discounts, financial stability and direct customer feedback from Jerry shoppers.

To calculate our 2026 Jerry Score rating, we analyzed over 1,200,000 actual policy quotes for real Jerry customers last year, across 100+ different insurers. This was used alongside data from independent industry sources covering financial strength, claims handling, customer satisfaction and customer complaints to create a proprietary score for our top insurance companies.

We regularly reassess insurers’ star ratings and fact-check these reviews to ensure they’re accurate and up-to-date. Each factor rolls up into a weighted composite score on a 1 to 5 scale.

What we measure

  • Claims and repair experience (16%)
  • Customer complaints (11%)
    • NAIC Complaint Index — current complaint volume relative to industry average (8%)
    • NAIC three-year trend — direction of complaint volume over time (3%)
  • Cost and value (11%)
    • Loss ratio — share of premium dollars paid out in claims, with scoring tuned to identify insurers in the healthy 65% to 78% middle ground (5%)
    • Discount and program density — count of available discounts and savings programs (6%)
  • Financial stability (15%)
  • Coverage and features (13%)
    • Breadth of optional coverages, telematics programs and rider availability
  • Customer experience (24%)
    • Clearsurance peer reviews — aggregated policyholder ratings (10%)
    • Mobile app — availability and average rating across iOS and Android (7%)
    • Better Business Bureau rating (7%)
  • Jerry customer reviews (10%)
    • Direct feedback from Jerry customers who hold or have held a policy with that insurer

Insurers must have data coverage of at least 60% across these measures to receive a composite score.

Editorial integrity

We’re all about balanced, unbiased and helpful content at Jerry. None of our articles are sponsored by advertisers or insurance companies, so you can trust the information we provide. As a comparison platform that works with 100+ insurers, Jerry has no reason to favor one insurer over another. Our job is to help you find the best fit for your situation.

Jerry does earn a commission from insurers when you purchase a policy through our platform. This does not affect our editorial ratings or insurer assessments, though, which are determined independently by our insurance experts. Click to read more about Jerry’s data gathering and verification processes.

Not all customers find savings. Savings depend on state, policy features, coverage, driving history and other features.
Editorial Note: This article was written by a paid member of Jerry’s editorial team. Statements in this article do not constitute advice or recommendations. You should consult with an insurance professional about your specific circumstances and needs before making any insurance decisions.
Jerry quotes 100+ insurers in as fast as 2 min.
Get Quotes